Let's Talk Paint: Part 2

Now that we have the background information on the Territory's historic town color schemes, let's establish the pre-approved colors that meet the paint color requirements for these districts. The St. Croix historic towns of Christiansted and Frederiksted are controlled by the St. Croix Historic Preservation Committee (STXHPC). The Charlotte Amalie/ Savan historic town is controlled by the St. Thomas/St. John Historic Preservation Committee (STT/STJHPC). These two committees make up the Virgin Islands Historic Preservation Commission (VIHPC). I've attached the color samples that are used in the St. Croix historic districts. The St. Thomas/St. John historic district has additional shutter colors that St. Croix does not use. As one can see, the recommended colors are soft pastel hues. This does not mean that these are the only colors allowed in the districts. As long as the colors are in this range, the VIHPC Committees will entertain other colors. All color selections whether pre-approved or new colors must be reviewed and approved  by the Committees prior to commencement of any painting of a building in the historic districts. This ensures the color schemes are authentic, relevant and enhance the aesthetic character of the towns and, more importantly, compliment the streetscape. These are unique historic towns that existed long before the arrival of our present day inhabitants and these towns have stewards, the VIHPC, who ensure they will exist long after we are gone and for future generations. 

I want to debunk some myths about using certain types of paint and colors in these historic towns. First, let's discuss the myth that dark colors cover up dirt and stains in this climate. I think most people would agree that a black car is one of the most elegant car colors on the market. Most of us probably would also agree that a black car is the most difficult car color to maintain and keep clean. In general, dark colors are hard to keep clean: dust and dirt are visible almost instantaneously on dark surfaces. If the rationale for using a dark color is because people put their feet up, lean against and dirty wall surfaces, then let's deal with the bad human behavior and stop punishing the building. Why is a dark wall color a bad thing on our historic buildings? With our intense Caribbean Sun, dark colors help heat up our buildings. From a sustainability and green building perspective, it is the "wrong way" to go. If you have a concrete block structure and you paint it a dark color in the Tropics, during the day, your cooling costs increase for a business or residence because the walls  "heat up". At night, if you have a residence, the heated block walls now expend the accumulated heat and keep your interiors way warm for awhile which requires mechanical cooling via a fan or A/C. In these hard economic times, this is not a good move. 

Dark brown painted base looks extremely dirty

Most people don't realize, our historic buildings, even our wonderful wooden vernacular structures, all have rubble wall construction as foundations and/or enclosure walls. What are "rubble walls"? They are thick masonry walls created from stones and bricks fused together with lime mortar. These thick walls that exist throughout our historic towns absorb moisture from the ground and from rain accumulated during showers and storms. They are always moist. Consequently, they need to have a coating that will allow them to breathe: expending this moisture through tiny air pockets in the surface. The only proper surface treatment that allows this moisture to escape is lime wash paint. Latex and alkyd based paints do not allow historic rubble walls to breathe. When latex paint is applied to a rubble wall, especially on the outside and inside surfaces, moisture becomes trapped in the wall. This causes the paint to spall (peel off) and actually damages the wall. Overtime, mold can grow between the plastic paint surface and rubble wall and can create an un-healthy living space. A closed space, as in an air conditioned building, compounds this problem and promotes mold growth even more. When you add a dark color in latex, you are truly creating a recipe for disaster. 

A previously lime wash painted rubble wall foundation covered over with latex paint in a dark burnt orange color ... a definite no no!

Here's a great example to analyze, especially right next to the historic town of Christiansted. Being an artist as well as an architect, I have to say there is an art to paring colors that allow them to be complimentary and pleasing to the eye. Dark colors against dark colors just don't work in this environment on so many levels. In this example, the stone base is the only "light colored" element saved on this building front and with the best intentions to uplift the surroundings, it doesn't quite hit the mark. 

Kudos to freshing up the exterior paint, but this doesn't really say St. Croix or Caribbean in my view.

Let's Talk Paint: Part 1

So let's get down to business and talk paint. Yes, paint, that visible element that affects the outward appearance of any structure here in the USVI. It's one of the most dominant features a building can have and has great implications when we are referring to structures in our historic districts or antiquities monuments that dot our landscapes. I'll begin with what was here historically and then show the evolution of paint color practices used and those that should be used today. The predominant color in our historic towns and monuments was white - white wash paint, lime based in composition and infused with white pigment. The second predominant pigment color used was ochre and hues of yellow. The third predominant pigment color used was a rose pigment. The cedar shingles found on many buildings, even today, were left natural which then turned from yellow/brown to silver grey color over time. In St. Thomas, the red colored metal roof was dominant while on St. Croix, the silver galvanized roof was most common replacing the earlier cedar shingled  roof. Therefore, the original paint scheme that existed here had an emphasis on light colors which were almost homogeneous (uniform:same) in character. The streetscape as a whole was the design intent, not the individual buildings, and  the composition of varying building types were used to create a dynamic and beautifully framed street lined with gutters, low walls and wells. Not only is there historical documentation through paint analysis of these structures, but there are historic color photographs that show this paint scheme. Let's take Prince Street in Christiansted as an example.

Prince Street Christiansted, 1910 Axel Oversen

Prince Street Christiansted, 1941 Jack Delano

Prince Street Christiansted, 2005

I believe even the 1910 black and white photograph depicts a more inviting and engaging street compared to the look of this street today. Jack Delano's 1941 color photograph is proof of the homogeneous yellow color paint scheme that dominated the streetscape with its silver and red roofs that drew you into the space and made you want to walk through and experience it. After Cuba closes in the 1950's and the USVI begins to develop itself as a tourist destination, the use of pastel colors become the norm for the streetscape that is required today. This multiple pastel color scheme, at times, makes the street look a bit more disparate and disjointed: a bit less inviting in my view. This is why having the expertise of our V.I. Historic Preservation Commission weigh in on a building's color selection if paramount and is the law of the land. When I hear people say "What our historic towns' need are brighter and louder colors", I have to say, these individuals don't know the history of this place and don't realize how sophisticated and well designed these towns are ... because they don't need bright and loud colors to define them.  Their fine detailing and superb proportions speak loudly enough and with a muted soft palette against a blazing Caribbean sun, these towns already have  a distinct calling card for anyone living here or visiting our shores. 

Why do all white walls with blue colored roofs scream Aegean architecture like on the island of Mykonos in Greece? Why have bright and jarring colors become associated with Caribbean architecture? It is my position that without fine detailing and superb proportioning in the architecture of a place, you need to use bright  jarring colors to give a structure character. Since that is not the case here, let's keep our own well defined signature color scheme on our sophisticated and unique architecture and brand this look: selling it to all who live here and visit our shores.

Cruz Bay, St. John 

"A garish color scheme in my view"

"We Preserve US.VI"?!!!

“We Preserve US.VI” … yes, it has a meaning: a play on words of course. Anyone who knows me, knows that this is one of my trademarks. We preserve US because if we don't who will? We preserve the USVI (United States Virgin Islands)  because it's those of us in the know that need to speak up about what is here, why it is here, how it got here and how we are going to keep it here. Why we all need to get involved is because if you are fed up with everyone else charting your course for you, try setting the compass yourself and experience how shaping your own destiny is beyond a spiritual experience and is truly fulfilling. Embark on a journey with me  to learn about this unique set of Caribbean islands: how culturally rich they are and how we can restore and develop them wisely and effectively.  By using preservation and conservation practices as an economic engine, we can  build truly amazing green and sustainable spaces here in the USVI.

Sunday Market Square, Christiansted (northside) looking down Company Street - Jack Delano Dec. 1941

King Street, Frederiksted - Jack Delano Dec. 1941

Main Street, Charlotte Amalie from Grand Hotel - Jack Delano Dec. 1941

vonRohr Cruz Bay Survey 1766 (Danish National Archives) via David Knight, Sr. 

- a new USVI historic district in the making (justifiably so)

Here You Go ... Gerville!

The obvious question is always: “Why create a blog?” and I have no apprehension in providing a response. You create a blog because you need to express a viewpoint and if any place needs a plethora of viewpoints is this place, the U.S. Virgin Islands. Steeped in history and culture, the U.S.V.I. is rich in its built and natural environments. You'd expect that everyone living here would conserve these rich attributes at all costs, but alas … no such luck. Where it is most prevalent that there is a community disconnect is our historic towns (Charlotte Amalie, Christiansted, Frederiksted & Cruz Bay) which, I'm afraid to say, continue to loose their historical character each and every day. I am a firm believer if we help educate the populace and they learn the importance and value of place ... this place, we will see these towns and our islands come back to life in the best ways possible. Help me help us achieve this super important goal!

My place, my interior, my sanctuary ... my inspiration